Integration and regulation within the energy sector. A Danish and European perspective

This project looked at the problems in establishing competitive electricity markets. There are many different angles to analyzing the evolution of newly established electricity markets. The project looked at it from two different angles: Different levels of analysis (industry and company) and different sectors (e.g. transmission).

Project description

The purpose of this project is to analyse alternative models in connection with the creation of competition within the electric power industry in Denmark. The project will focus on development within Denmark as well as on the consequences of an increasing integration, both in Scandinavia as a whole and in relation to the creation of a European market. The analysis will be based on several behavioural simulation models which emphasize feedback, lags, and binding rational decision making. The creation of markets for electric power is characterised by complex interactions between many different time scales, long delays, a number of 'soft issues', environmental concerns and feedback. It is often hard to discover the points of leverage in this type of system; the most obvious solution is often the least desirable in the long term and one can not depend on one strategy alone. The use of strategic simulation models can help to unravel many of these problems, not by making forecasts, but by providing the opportunity to understand the long term consequences of a given set of assumptions

Results

We point out in the project that there is a big difference between the level of analysis and the implications of designing new electricity markets. Where most regulatory frameworks are designed at industry level, with some implicit assumptions about the rationality of the individual company, the reality often look very different when the famework is implemented. Companies are inert and the transition they need to go through is on a scale not found in any other industry outside the utility sector. This slow change both in culture and the way the organization conducts its daily routine often is far from the behavior assumed in the regulatory framework. This creates tension both within the specific companies as well as in the way the industry as a whole evolves. Using scenario techniques we look at the condition that are needed before a single market for electricity in Europe can be created and conclude that we are more likely to observe the creation of local (regional) markets rather than the ideal of a single market. We also look at the issucs around transmissions, which potentially is one of the most complicated areas of deregulation in terms of pricing and possible future competition. Furthermore, a model describing the theoretical evolution and behavior of a non-profit market is being developed to describe what the likely side effects of such a market might be

Key figures

Period:
1997 - 1998
Funding year:
1997
Own financial contribution:
0.00 mio. DKK
Grant:
0.68 mio. DKK
Funding rate:
100 %
Project budget:
0.68 mio. DKK

Category

Oprindelig title
Regulering og integration i energisektoren. Et dansk og europæisk perspektiv
Programme
EFP
Project type
Analyse
Case no.
1753/97-0001

Participants

Handelshøjskolen i København. (Main Responsible)
Partners and economy
Partner Subsidy Auto financing
Roskilde Universitet

Contact

Kontakperson
Haxholdt, Christian
Comtact information
Handelshøjskolen i København. Institut for Matematisk Erhvervsøkonomi og Statistik
Julius Thomsens Plads 10
DK-1925 Frederiksberg C, Denmark
Haxholdt, Christian (ph.d., adjunkt); Projektleder: Larsen, Erik Reimer (dr., Univ. of Bologna), 38153515, stch@gibson.mes.cbs.dk
Øvr. Partnere: ELSAM; Danske Elværkers Forening; Roskilde Universitetscenter; Energistyrelsen. 6 kontor

Energiforskning.dk - informationportal for danish energytechnology research- og development programs.

Logo innovationsfonden
Logo for EUDP
Logo for elforsk